In January 1995, an editorial in The Wall Street Journal called Canada โan honorary member of the Third Worldโ because of its debt problem. Years of deficits made the country vulnerable to rising borrowing costs. Interest payments on the countryโs debt consumed 35 cents of every revenue dollar collected by Canadaโs federal government. These woes were the culmination of decades of borrowing.
Instead of ending in tragedy, the Liberal government in Ottawa responded with spending cuts that even the most ardent American fiscal hawks would consider politically impossible. The efforts helped avert a deeper fiscal crisis and demonstrated that governments can change course.
As US Treasury note yields rise, our neighbor to the northโs experience offers us a clear lesson: The only choice regarding fiscal reform is whether it happens on our terms or on the bond marketโs terms.
Canadaโs Fiscal Crunch
The fiscal crunch of the 1990s started like most budget crises. The seeds were sown thirty years earlier by the conscious choices of Canadian policymakers to paper over deficits with debt. The runaway deficits partially came from the mistaken belief that government spending and budget deficits could promote economic growth. Fred Barnes notes that the Liberal government of Pierre Trudeau (a premiership that lasted from 1968 to 1984) eagerly spent and borrowed in the hopes that Canadians would prosper.
The temptation crossed party lines. Barnes quotes Finance Minister Paul Martin (who would be part of the effort to reverse the damage in 1995), who warned: โOnce you break the spell โ once governments find that they can get away with borrowing instead of taxing to pay the bills โ it is almost impossibly tempting for politicians to do it again and again until the debt is out of control.โ
This was evident in the conservative government that replaced the Liberal Trudeau premiership. The Progressive Conservative government under Brian Mulroney (which lasted from 1984 to 1993) trimmed some spending but failed to eliminate the deficit and the debt continued to grow. High interest rates, reinforced by central banksโ efforts to tame inflation, compounded the problem. Canadaโs debt-to-GDP ratio rose from 47 percent to 67 percent by the time Mulroney left office in 1993. In government, incentives to spend will beat out ideology.ย
In 1993, the new Liberal government under Prime Minister Jean Chrรฉtien inherited a government under severe fiscal strain. It first attempted to cut specific areas of spending โ unemployment benefits, defense, business subsidies, and government operating expenditures โ but rising interest rates undermined these efforts. In response, the government launched Program Review, a zero-based budgeting approach to the federal budget. The Mexican Peso Crisis in December 1994 and critical newspaper coverage in early 1995 convinced Ottawa to act urgently and boldly.
Program Review required ministers from various departments (all part of Canadaโs federal executive branch for the American readers) to reconsider the fundamentals of each department. Finance officials and other central agencies scrutinized proposals before Cabinet settled the decisions. Ministers had to identify activities to reduce or end, requiring them to focus on the scope of government instead of searching for line items in the budget to trim. To achieve this, spending assessments revolved around the following six questions:
- Does the program serve the public interest?
- Is it affordable?
- Is government intervention necessary?
- What is the appropriateness of the federal governmentโs involvement?
- Is there potential for private/public sector cooperation?
- Is it efficient?
Prioritizing spending and scope of authority reductions over tax hikes paid off handsomely. Deficit reduction targets were exceeded, cutting $12 billion in spending from the 1994-95 budget to the 1996-97 budget. In 1997-98, Canada had the first budget surplus in 30 years, a status maintained through 2007-08. The spending reductions were assisted by economic growth and declining borrowing rates.ย
Program Review took a broad approach, but its formal scope excluded โmajor statutory transfers,โ such as Old-Age Security and federal support for provincial health care, which had to be addressed through separate budget measures.
These solutions, however, did not solve all of Canadaโs problems. The country kept high taxes and spending throughout the period of reform and remained heavily indebted. In 1998, an article in The Wall Street Journal noted, โThe real challenge Canada and many other countries face is the fact that there has been no real change in the attitude toward the appropriate role of government โ at least at the federal level.โ
Canadaโs achievement was substantial, but it did not follow through on maintaining long-term spending restraint.
The US: Higher Interest Costs Without an Official Crisis
As 2026 draws to a close, the yield on Treasuries remains near historic highs. As of this writing, the 10-year Treasury yielded 4.98 percent, the 20-year 5.39 percent, and the 30-year 5.35 percent. Debt held by the public is reported by Bloomberg to be over 100 percent of GDP (FRED puts the Q2 2026 measurement at a mere 97.4 percent).ย
While interest rates on government debt are influenced by factors beyond the governmentโs control (economic conditions, demand for Treasury notes, inflation expectations), spending habits do play a role in its credit rating. The credit downgrades from S&P (2011), Fitch (2023), and Moodyโs (2025) have all cited rising entitlement spending, widening deficits, and skepticism about DCโs ability to course-correct. Nearly 14 cents of every dollar the federal government spends is dedicated to net interest payments on the debt, and these payments are expected to take up increasingly larger portions of total spending.ย
While most Treasury notes carry fixed interest rates and are relatively insulated from higher market yields, the pressure builds as older securities mature and the Treasury wants to refinance debt. Combined with taking on new debt to paper over deficits, Congress is left facing tighter spending tradeoffs, higher taxes, more borrowing, or leaning on the Federal Reserve to accommodate fiscal policy.
While the dollarโs reserve currency status and deep Treasury markets give the US greater latitude to spend than its neighbor to the north, there is still a valuable lesson to be learned from Canadaโs experience. As was seen in Canada previously and in the US now, policymakers and citizens can feel the pressure of excessive borrowing long before investors lose confidence.
Why Governments Wait for Financial Pressure
Governments postpone spending restraint because its political costs arrive before the benefits. Cutting programs and agencies (as was seen with DOGE in 2025) can draw the ire of bureaucrats, politicians, and the interest groups that benefit from the agency or program under scrutiny. Meanwhile, lower debt and interest costs benefit taxpayers in less visible ways. As long as there is demand for Treasury securities, lawmakers can preserve benefits without immediately collecting enough taxes to pay for them.
As debt and interest costs increase, each budget decision then becomes more contentious. Each trifecta of interest groups, elected officials, and bureaucrats will ardently fight to resist reductions to their favored program or agency, intensifying budget battles. As my colleague Ryan Yonk and I previously discussed, radical budget politics stems from a system that promises concentrated benefits, disperses costs, and postpones facing budget realities.
Canadaโs experience suggests that such financial pressures make reform politically feasible by raising the cost of inaction. Unlike the US, Canadaโs centralized budget process means that there are fewer actors with spending authority. Once the finance minister proposes a budget, the Canadian parliament can only approve the budget, reduce the proposed budget, or reject the budget. In the US, the two houses of Congress and the president are not all constrained by the same budgetary rules, and Congress contains multiple committees with spending authority.
Despite the relatively simpler budget process, however, Chrรฉtien and Martin still needed to build a durable coalition. Some of the success is credited to Martinโs efforts to explain the tradeoffs and political implications of inaction. He emphasized that controlling the deficit and debt was essential to preserving the spending the Liberal Party supported.
A key lesson for America here is that even in a moment of crisis, durable solutions will require a broad coalition of supporters.
Fiscal Reform: On Our Terms or the Bond Marketโs?
When it comes to fiscal reform, lawmakers are faced with a question of โWhen?โ even though they treat the question as an โIf?โ Congress can choose how these changes get phased in so long as investors are willing to lend money at reasonable interest rates. Acting now gives households and businesses time to prepare, but, as previously mentioned, the US faces some distinct institutional and incentive challenges compared to Canada.
A Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) model applied to the federal budget could help overcome the unique institutional challenges facing the US federal budget process. This model would be independent and given clear criteria for carrying out fiscal reforms. Those criteria could be modeled on Canadaโs Program Review questions or similar examples from here in the states such as Washington Stateโs Priorities of Government or Priority-Based Budgeting.
Additionally, the commissionโs reform package would be reviewed by a nonpartisan government body to certify its recommendations are sound before being sent to the President for approval. If approved, the reform package gets sent to Congress in its entirety. If Congress wants to reject the package, it must do so by passing a joint resolution of both houses rejecting the package. Once enacted, future governments will need to enact budget rules to limit how much government can spend and regulatory reforms to limit the scope of government authority.
Canada changed course before losing access to credit. Congress still has that opportunity. It should learn from Canadaโs efforts in the 1990s and then build on them by establishing durable limits on spending.
Share This Article

Post on Facebook

Post on X

Print Article

Email Article




